Even before the coronavirus, we were not big fans of the airlines business. Planes are expensive. Airlines have to pay for them whether they are fully occupied during normal economic times or when they are half-loaded during recessions. Their other big cost is fuel - airlines have little control over it. If they hedge the oil price and it goes up, they are heroes. If they hedge oil and it declines, their unhedged competition will have an economic advantage. It is very difficult to develop competitive advantage; customers usually have very little loyalty and price is the deciding factor for most buying decisions.
Warren Buffett (Trades, Portfolio) invested in the airlines industry in the '80s, lost money, and swore he'd never invest in it again. However, after the Great Financial Crisis the industry went through significant consolidation by mergers and attrition, leaving four carriers controlling the bulk of the market. Fewer competitors made competition more rational and turned these airlines into much better businesses. So Buffett changed his mind and bought a 10% stake in all four of the largest U.S. airlines. For a few years it seemed that he was finally right about the airlines.
Airlines were never our cup of tea. The high fixed-cost structure of the industry and its past history of going bankrupt every other recession made our EQ when it comes to airlines very low. When Buffett bought them, for some value investors, the airlines had been blessed by the high priest. We are agnostic (growing up in Soviet Russia has its rare benefits) and have to own our decisions, so we passed on the airlines without spending much time thinking about them.
Typically, when you go into recession you can look at the rear-view mirror earnings for a cyclical company and that becomes your goalpost for future earnings power within a year or two, max. We don't know how long it will take until we'll again see the 2019 earnings power of airlines and the travel industry in general. Here is what we know. Though it is hard to imagine this today, the fear of COVID-19 will eventually go away, either because there is a vaccine or a cure, or because the virus is gone, or because we will simply adapt to its existence.
But even in absence of a vaccine or cure, we'll change our behavior, and that will happen slowly on the margin. After being locked up for a few months, not seeing friends and relatives except on Zoom or Facetime, we'll timidly visit their houses and sit six feet apart on their porches. (My family did this on Mother's Day.) Then we'll invite very close friends - the ones who stuck religiously to social distancing- to our homes for dinner. Then we might chance visiting a restaurant with outdoor seating. Then, on a rainy day, we'll go inside the restaurant and find that it now has huge spacing between the tables. We'll make a lot of small incremental decisions; each will be a tiny compromise that will nudge us out of our fear.
Of course, each time we read about serious virus flareups, we'll take one step back.
Flying is at one extreme in the spectrum of social distancing. It requires finding your way through airports packed with people and then getting on a plane that, even after the middle seats are removed will still have a higher density than a packed bar on Friday night in Manhattan. Thus flying will require a great many little, incremental, marginal decisions before we overcome the fear of boarding a plane.
Vaccine availability would instantly vanquish fear, and our behavior would come back to normal. Well, almost. There will be scar tissue on the economy - trillions in government debt and persistently high unemployment - that will take time to clear up. People are not flying today because we are in lockdown; they'll be flying less than they used to after lockdown is over because they are still afraid; and after their fear is gone they'll still be flying less because they cannot afford the flights.
We imagine that when Buffett bought airlines in 2015, he thought the worst case would be a significant recession where plane occupancy would fall from the usual 80-90% to 50-60% (according to the FT, only four airlines out of a few hundred are profitable at 62% occupancy). His thinking was that the airlines would lose some money for a few quarters, but the recession would be anything but an existential crisis for them. Recessions last months and expansion years, and he thought he had bought them cheap on full-cycle (both recession and expansion) earnings.
Story continues
Despite being the Oracle of Omaha, he did not foresee that one day we might have a different type of recession where 95% of the planes would be grounded, not because people couldn't afford to buy a tickets but because they would be required to stay home by their governments, or would be afraid that close proximity to others would make them sick or even kill them.
Very few businesses can survive when 95% of their revenue goes away for an extended period of time. Even fewer can survive when they have a large fixed-asset base that needs to be paid for whether they are using it or not.
The sad reality is that unless airlines raise new capital, they will go bankrupt. This capital, though it might save them, will reduce the value of their businesses. Equity issuances, especially at today's depressed stock prices, would permanently dilute shareholders, as future earnings will be shared with a much-increased shareholder base.
If the airlines issue debt, it will not be cheap capital, either, and will burden these companies, which already have a lot of fixed costs, with another cost - significant interest payments that will substantially reduce their future earnings power. The longer the fear of the virus lingers on, the more money these companies will lose and the greater the damage that will be done to their balance sheets and thus their future earnings power.
In our thinking about the virus we have three timelines, or eras: BC - before coronavirus, DC - during coronavirus (now), and AC - after coronavirus (the virus is completely gone, or there is a vaccine or effective treatment. The longer the DC era lasts the more impact it has on the AC era. The DC era comes with high unemployment and enormous government spending - larger deficits and an ever-growing debt pile that is no longer counted in billions but in trillions.
The future of the airlines is path-dependent, and they have little control over that path; it is controlled by the virus (or the fear of the virus).
We don't own airlines, so why am I spending so much time talking about them? There are several reasons. First, because they are companies that are antithetical to our portfolio philosophy. Charlie Munger (Trades, Portfolio) says, "Tell me where I am going to die so I won't go there." So it's worth having a clear picture of the types of businesses you don't want to own.
Second, we wanted to point out Buffett's ability to change his mind. Interestingly, Buffett, who was already the largest shareholder of U.S. airlines, bought more airline stocks a few weeks before he sold them. We did something similar this quarter, too: We increased our position in Melrose Industries, just to sell the full position two weeks later. (More about Melrose to follow).
Third, like Buffett, we were playing traditional chess, not realizing that the game had changed to Fischer random chess. We were following the normal recession handbook (mental models) but then realized that this is anything but a normal recession. We have to be incredibly careful about using our past mental models today; they were built in a very different environment. Today, past experience is not useless, but if relied on blindly it can be dangerous. Some things will play out in the future as they have in the past, but many won't.
We needed to start using a first-principles approach - a concept we shamelessly borrowed from physics. We took out a blank piece of paper, assumed we knew nothing, and instead of continuing to think by analogy, started questioning every assumption we make in our analysis.
Our decision to sell Melrose Industries (LSE:MRO) is very similar to Buffett's sale of the airlines. We sold Melrose before the Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE:BRK.A)(NYSE:BRK.B) annual meeting. It was a difficult decision, not because we cemented a loss but because we parted with a business we really liked, that was run by good management, and that was significantly undervalued when we bought it.
When we were buying Melrose we stress-tested it for a severe recession; however, the decline that Melrose is probably experiencing today did not occur to us in our wildest imagination. Melrose is a very strong player in two industries that have been impacted tremendously: the airlines space (it makes parts that go into planes and engines) and car parts (it is one of the largest makers of transmissions for cars). We talked to the company. It has credit lines and cash to give it immediate liquidity, but we are not sure if it will be enough.
We had applied the traditional recession mental model to our analysis, and we were wrong. Given the world we are looking at now, we should have sold it sooner.
Buying new planes is the last thing on airlines' minds today. Also, only 20% of Melrose's business comes from replacement parts. Melrose's auto parts business (ironically, the business we worried about the most when we bought the stock) may be okay; it may even generate some profit; but we are not sure it will be able to sustain the company. We simply don't know what the losses are going to be in the airlines space and for how long. We have a tremendous respect for the Melrose management team - they're a big reason why we bought the stock - but at this point the problem that Melrose is facing is bigger than them.
If you look carefully through your portfolio, you'll see that we've positioned it to the opposite side of spectrum from the airlines. Most of our holdings are concentrated in four industries: defense, healthcare, tobacco (where we are permitted by clients), and telecommunications. These industries have one thing in common: They will not be structurally impacted by the virus.
Consumption of goods and services in the four industries is completely insensitive to the virus. These companies all have very stable cash flows and pricing power - in the event of deflation they'll maintain their prices, while during inflation they'll raise them.
And one more thing...
I am not a journalist or reporter; I am an investor who thinks through writing. This and other investment articles are just my thinking at the point they were written. However, investment research is not static, it is fluid. New information comes our way and we continue to do research, which may lead us to tweak and modify assumptions and thus to change our minds.
We are long-term investors and often hold stocks for years, but as luck may or may not have it, by the time you read this article we may have already sold the stock. I may or may not write about this company ever again. Think of this and other articles as learning and thinking frameworks. But they are not investment recommendations. The bottom line is this. If this article piques your interest in the company I've mentioned, great. This should be the beginning, not the end, of your research.
Vitaliy Katsenelson, CFA
Student of Life
I am the CEO at IMA, which is anything but your average investment firm. (Why? Get our company brochure in your inbox here, or simply visit our website.)
In a brief moment of senility, Forbes magazine called me "the new Benjamin Graham."
I've written two books on investing, which were published by John Wiley & Sons and have been translated into eight languages. (I'm working on a third - you can read a chapter from it, titled "The 6 Commandments of Value Investing" here.)
And if you prefer listening, audio versions of my articles are published weekly at investor.fm.
This article first appeared on GuruFocus.
Read more:
When the Facts Change, We Change Our Minds (Anatomy of a Sale) - Yahoo Finance
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Star Kevin McKidd Announces the Death of His Father: 'Grateful for the Years of Love and Laughter' - PEOPLE - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Invisible anatomy in the fruit fly uterus: New discoveries could have implications for fertility and pest control - Phys.org - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Scott Speedman explains how he gets in trouble on Grey's Anatomy set - Digital Spy - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- 'One Tree Hill' Fans Won't Believe Which Star Is Heading to 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 21 - Good Housekeeping - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Anatomy of Lies Duo on Greys Ex-Writer Elisabeth Finch: 'More to Story' - Hollywood Reporter - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Just Confirmed Schmitt's Exit Storyline Can Be His Best Happily Ever After - Screen Rant - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- The Anatomy and Aftermath of a PWHL Trade - The Hockey News - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Tackles Voter Responsibility in Last Episode Before 2024 Election - TheWrap - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Jo Snaps on Link When His Primary Concern About Expecting Twins Is Getting a Minivan (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Camilla Luddington Has One Wish For Her Greys Anatomy Pregnancy, And Im Not Sure I Agree - CinemaBlend - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- How Vanessa Parise Brought the Classic Greys Anatomy Magic to the Screen - Shondaland.com - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Trump speech turns bizarre with praise for Arnold Palmers anatomy and profanity for Harris - Fortune - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Anatomy of a Bad Trip: On the Less-Than-Magical Side of Magic Mushrooms - Literary Hub - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Deconstructing Art: Anatomy of a Killer Clown - Hollywood Reporter - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy actor Kevin McKidd is mourning death of his dad - Yahoo New Zealand News - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Jason George On Returning to 'Grey's Anatomy' and Memorable Moments On Screen - EBONY - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Sarah Drew Clears Up Her Viral 'Grey's Anatomy' Firing Comments - Us Weekly - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Is Patrick Dempsey Returning For Scream 7? Heres The Latest From The Greys Anatomy Alum - CinemaBlend - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Every Grey's Anatomy Doctor Who's Been Fired (& Why) - CBR - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Cast Shares Behind-The-Scenes Look on Set, Reflect on Shows 21-Year-Run & Impact on Fans - Hollywood Reporter - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Fans Are Both Angry And Hopeful After That Carina Name-Drop, And Im Conflicted About What It Could Mean - CinemaBlend - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21's Amelia Story Honored 1 Of Derek Shepherd's Best Case From 15 Years Ago - Screen Rant - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Jason George Teases Ben and Bailey's Big Hurdle - Us Weekly - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Season 21 Casts New Recurring Character, Connection To Main Character Revealed - Screen Rant - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Jason George Compares Grey's Anatomy Return to 'Coming Back to Your Parents' House' But with 'New Faces' (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Reveals How 1 Major Character Exit Will Happen (& It Follows A Horrible Trend) - Screen Rant - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Catherine's Secret Is Revealed, Meredith and Richard Face Off and Ben Stands Up for Himself - PEOPLE - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Review: 'Anatomy of Lies' Reveals the Depths of Elisabeth Finch, a Very Nasty Scammer - Pajiba Entertainment News - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' recap: Catherine's life is on the line in a liver-centric episode - Entertainment Weekly News - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Season 21: Check out episode schedule, where to watch and cast - The Economic Times - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- The anatomy of 3 videos alleging that many non-citizens are registered to vote in U.S. elections - UW Center for an Informed Public - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Out of the Line of Fire: Station 19 Star Jason George on Returning to Greys Anatomy - Shondaland.com - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of a Swing State Harris vs. Trump October 11th - 1290 WJNO - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Anatomy of a Recession: The case for economic reacceleration | Franklin Templeton - Beyond Bulls & Bears - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Round Table: Blues Pointless Arc, the Doomed Mika/Jules Ship & Problematic Catherine - Seithikkural - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Deceitful Love review: Grey's Anatomy hunk keeps everyone guessing in lusty age-gap mystery - RadioTimes - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Boss on More Ellen Pompeo and Pushing Boundaries in Season 21 - Hollywood Reporter - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Star Camilla Luddington on Sticking With the Show for 13 Seasons, Jos Pregnancy and Alex Choosing Izzie - Variety - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 21: How to Watch Without Cable - CNET - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Showrunner Talks Premieres Twists & Big Return, Teases Resilience-Themed Season 21 As 2 Cast Members Prepare To Exit - Deadline - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Season-Premiere Recap: A Slap in the Face - Vulture - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Boss Addresses Season 21 Premiere Slap Fakeout: We All Have Those Moments - TheWrap - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- 'Greys Anatomy': Meredith Is Blackmailed, Jos Secret Is Exposed and Baileys Fate Is Revealed in Season 21 Premiere - PEOPLE - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Photos from Grey's Anatomy's Departed Doctors: Where Are They Now? - E! Online - E! NEWS - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Here's Everything We Know About 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 22 - Cosmopolitan - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- How Greys Anatomy Keeps Upping the Drama: Sex, Disasters and More Than 140 Tumors - The Wall Street Journal - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Star Chandra Wilson Reflects On 21 Seasons: It Is My Greatest Honor - Forbes - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Checking In With Justin Chambers, Patrick Dempsey and More Departed Grey's Anatomy Doctors - E! NEWS - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Catherine's Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Problem Resolution Was Already Revealed Two Years Ago - Screen Rant - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Showrunner Addresses Two Actors Leaving the Show in Middle of Season 21 - Just Jared - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- A Greys Anatomy Catch-up Guide, No Matter How Far Behind You Are - Vulture - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 22: Will It Happen? Everything We Know - Screen Rant - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Volcanic Anatomy, Mapped as It Erupts - Eos - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Premiere's Big Lie Is A Wasted Opportunity For 1 Original Character - Screen Rant - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Rita Puig-Serra On Her Exhibition Anatomy Of An Oyster At PhMuseum Lab - PHmuseum - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- How to watch Grey's Anatomy season 21 online for free and from anywhere 2024 episodes - TechRadar - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Dives Into The Interns Love Lives In Season 21 Premiere, But Im Super Annoyed About One Couple - CinemaBlend - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- How to watch 'Grey's Anatomy' season 21 online from anywhere - Tom's Guide - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy airs touching tribute to Stephanie Leifer in season 21 premiere - Digital Spy - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Camilla Luddington Teases on Jo's 'Tornado of Emotions' (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- How to watch the season premiere of Greys Anatomy with a FREE live stream - PennLive - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Season 21 Premiere Recap: Reversal of Misfortune Plus, That Steamy Kiss Damn - TVLine - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Oliwood feat. Evans, Mahall, Landfermann - Anatomy of Anarchy (Jazzwerkstatt, 2024) - The Free Jazz Collective - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Is 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 21 Streaming? Where To Watch the Highly-Anticipated Return to Grey Sloan - Collider - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Boss Teases How New 10 p.m. Timeslot Could Lead to Boundary-Pushing Story Lines - Us Weekly - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Jason George revives 'Grey's Anatomy' role as Dr. Ben Warren returns to the show - Scripps News - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Release Date, Trailer and Everything to Know - Us Weekly - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Anatomy of a crash: We just happened to be on motorcycles - The Globe and Mail - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Transformers One | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Kathryn Crosby death: Anatomy of a Murder actor and Bing Crosbys widow dies aged 90 - The Independent - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Anatomy of Lies: Inside the Twisty Story of the Greys Anatomy Scammer - Vanity Fair - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- The 10 Best Meredith Grey Quotes From 'Grey's Anatomy,' Ranked - Collider - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy writer who lied about having cancer is subject of Peacock docuseries - New York Post - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- For Years She Fooled Hollywood: Peacock Reveals Docuseries Based on Greys Anatomy Writer Case - Hollywood Reporter - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Anatomy of a Fall Outfit MK2 Inks Multi-Year Financing Deal With IPR.VC - Hollywood Reporter - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Anatomy Of Lies trailer recounts tangled web of untruths from ex- Grey's Anatomy writer - The A.V. Club - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Favorites 'Did Not Get Along' When They Met - Newsweek - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Peacock Docseries to Cover Grey's Anatomy Writer Who Lied About Cancer - Us Weekly - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- The Greys Anatomy S21 Trailer: Fights, Slaps, and Golf? - Shondaland.com - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- An anatomy of Arsenals away wins in 2024: Free-flowing thrashings, contained opportunism - The Athletic - The New York Times - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]