Home > Judgments
Case summary coming soon
Case numbers omitted Neutral Citation Number: [2017] EWHC 784 (Fam) IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICEFAMILY DIVISION
Royal Courts of Justice Strand, London, WC2A 2LL
Date: 12 April 2017
Before :
SIR JAMES MUNBY PRESIDENT OF THE FAMILY DIVISION
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
In the Matter of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases Y, Z, AA, AB and AC)
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Ms Deirdre Fottrell QC (instructed by Goodman Ray Solicitors LLP) for the applicants
Hearing date: 21 March 2017
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Judgment This judgment was handed down in open court
Sir James Munby, President of the Family Division : 1.Since I handed down judgment in In re A and others (Legal Parenthood: Written Consents) [2015] EWHC 2602 (Fam), [2016] 1 WLR 1325, I have had to consider a number of cases raising issues very similar to those which confront me here. The most recent judgments were Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases P, Q, R, S, T, U, W and X) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam) and Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Case K) [2016] EWHC 2356 (Fam). They were the sixteenth to twenty-fourth of these cases in which I have given a final judgment. This judgment relates to another five cases, Cases Y, Z, AA, AB and AC. That amounts to 29 cases in all. There are at least another five cases in the pipeline, Cases AD, AE, AF, AG and AH.
2.For the purposes of this judgment I shall take as read the analysis in In re A and the summary of the background to all this litigation which appears in Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Case O) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam).
The facts3.For reasons which will by now be familiar, I propose to be extremely sparing in what I say of the facts and the evidence in these cases.
4.All relate to treatment provided by Care Fertility Group Manchester, except Case X which relates to treatment provided by Care Fertility Group Manchester. Each of the clinics is and was regulated by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. I shall refer to the applicant in each case as X, the respondent as Y and the child as C. In each case X seeks a declaration pursuant to section 55A of the Family Law Act 1986 that he or she is, in accordance with sections 36 and 37 or, as the case may be, sections 43 and 44 of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008, the legal parent of C. In each case Y is wholeheartedly supportive of X's application. In each case the clinic, the HFEA, the Secretary of State for Health and the Attorney General have all been notified of the proceedings. None has sought to be joined, although representatives of Care Fertility Group attended the hearing. In each case, given the nature of the issues (see below) I decided that there was no need for C to have a guardian appointed.
5.I heard the cases sequentially, in the order Case Y, Case AA, Case AC, Case AB and Case Z, on 21 March 2017. In each case X was represented by Ms Deirdre Fottrell QC. At the end of each of the hearings I indicated that I was making the orders sought. I now (xx April 2017) hand down judgment explaining my reasons.
6.Although I am acutely conscious of the stress, worry and anxiety burdening all the parents in these cases, and of the powerful human emotions that are inevitably engaged, each of these cases is, in terms of the applicable legal analysis, straight-forward and simple. They raise no new points. In each case the evidence, which there is no need for me to rehearse in detail, is compelling. In each case the answer is clear.
7.Just as in each of the other cases I have had to consider, so in each of these cases, having regard to the evidence before me, I find as a fact that:
i)The treatment which led to the birth of C was embarked upon and carried through jointly and with full knowledge by both the woman (that is, Y) and her partner (X).
ii)From the outset of that treatment, it was the intention of both X and Y that X would be a legal parent of C. Each was aware that this was a matter which, legally, required the signing by each of them of consent forms. Each of them believed that they had signed the relevant forms as legally required and, more generally, had done whatever was needed to ensure that they would both be parents.
iii)From the moment when the pregnancy was confirmed, both X and Y believed that X was the other parent of the child. That remained their belief when C was born.
iv)X and Y, believing that they were entitled to, and acting in complete good faith, registered the birth of their child, as they believed C to be, showing both of them on the birth certificate as C's parents, as they believed themselves to be.
v)The first they knew that anything was or might be 'wrong' was when, some while later, they were contacted by the clinic.
8.I add that there can be no suggestion that any consent given was not fully informed consent. Nor is there any suggestion of any failure or omission by the clinic in relation to the provision of information or counselling.
The facts: the individual cases9.In each of Cases Y, AA, AC and AB the applicant is a woman. In Case Z the applicant is a man. None of them was either in a civil partnership with or married to the respondent mother.
10.Case Y: Adopting the terminology I have used in previous cases, the problem in this case is very shortly stated. The Form PP was correctly completed. There is no Form WP in the clinic's records. X and Y do not assert any positive memory of a Form WP. Ms Fottrell invites me to proceed on the basis that there is a Form IC, signed by both X and Y, in a form which, on the basis of my judgments in previous cases, suffices to entitle X to the declaration she seeks. The relevant declaration, signed by X, reads as follows:
"I am the partner of [Y]. I acknowledge that she and I are being treated together In consenting to the course of treatment outlined above, I understand that I will become the legal parent of any resulting child(ren) subject to the completion of the appropriate HFEA consent forms [see page 1, section 4 of this consent]."
That cross-reference is to Forms WP and PP. But for the inclusion of the words "subject to the completion of the appropriate HFEA consent forms", there could be no question of this not being a Form IC sufficient to entitle X to the declaration she seeks. The only question is whether those words are fatal to the efficacy of the document for this purpose. In my judgment they are not. The document has to be read as a whole and, read as a whole, it is clear that both parties were signing a document which contemplated that X would be a parent. If X was not to be a parent, why sign the declaration at all? X is entitled to the declaration she seeks: see In re A, para 63(iii).
11.Case AA: Again, the problem is very shortly stated. The Form WP was properly completed. The Form PP contains two errors: first, Y's name, rather than X's, appears in section 1, and X's name, rather than Y's, appears in section 2; secondly, the declaration in section 5 has been signed by Y and not by X. However, and importantly, the consent box in section 3 has been ticked and the second page, which contains section 3, has been signed at the foot by X. Both errors are obvious. The first error, the transposition of the names, can be corrected by way of rectification: see In re A, para 47, Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Case G) [2016] EWHC 729 (Fam) and Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases P, Q, R, S, T, U, W and X) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam), paras 17 (Case S) and 18 (Case T). The second error is irrelevant: see Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases P, Q, R, S, T, U, W and X) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam), paras 13 (Case Q) and 15 (Case R). X's signature at the foot of the second page is sufficient to satisfy the statutory requirement: see Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases P, Q, R, S, T, U, W and X) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam), paras 13 (Case Q) and 15 (Case R). In these circumstances X is entitled to a decree of rectification and the declaration she seeks.
12.Case AC: Again, the problem is very shortly stated. The Form WP was properly completed. In the Form PP, Y's name, rather than X's, appears in section 1, and X's name, rather than Y's, appears in section 2. However, the consent box in section 3 has been ticked, the second page, which contains section 3, has been signed at the foot by X, as has the declaration in section 5. The error is obvious. The transposition of the names can be corrected by way of rectification: see the authorities referred to in paragraph 11 above. X is entitled to a decree of rectification and the declaration she seeks.
13.Moreover, there is again a quite separate ground on which X is entitled to the relief she seeks. Both Y and X signed a Form IC which, in all material respects, was in the same form as the Form IC considered in paragraph 10 above. In the circumstances, X is, in principle, entitled to the declaration she seeks on this ground also.
14.Case AB: Again, the problem is shortly stated. The Form PP was properly completed. In the Form WP, which was otherwise properly completed, the consent box in section 3 on the second page was not ticked. The omission of the ? in the consent box is not fatal to the validity either of a Form PP or, as here, of a Form WP: see Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Case J) [2016] EWHC 1330 (Fam), para 15, followed by Peter Jackson J in D v D (Fertility Treatment: Paperwork Error) [2016] EWHC 2112 (Fam), and Re the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (Cases P, Q, R, S, T, U, W and X) [2016] EWHC 2273 (Fam), paras 11 (Case P) and 17 (Case S). X is entitled to the declaration she seeks.
15.Again, there is a quite separate ground on which X is entitled to the relief she seeks. Both Y and X signed a Form IC which, in all material respects, was in the same form as the Forms IC considered in paragraphs 10 and 13 above. In the circumstances, X is, in principle, entitled to the declaration she seeks on this ground also.
16.Case Z: Again, the problem is shortly stated. The Form WP was properly completed. In the Form PP, which was otherwise properly completed, the consent box in section 3 on the second page was not ticked. The omission of the ? in the consent box is not fatal to the validity either of a Form WP or, as here, of a Form PP: see the authorities referred to in paragraph 14 above. X is entitled to the declaration he seeks.
17.Again, there is again a quite separate ground on which X is entitled to the relief he seeks. Both Y and X signed a Form IC, indeed a number of Forms IC, which, in all material respects, were in the same form as the Forms IC considered in paragraphs 10, 13 and 15 above. X is, in principle, entitled to the declaration he seeks on this ground also.
Outcome18.It was for these reasons that at the conclusion of the hearing of each case I made a declaration in the terms sought by X.
Costs19.In each case the clinic has very properly agreed to pay the applicant's reasonable costs.
Read the original:
Re Cases Y, Z, AA, AB & AC (Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008) [2017] EWHC 784 (Fam) - Family Law Week
- World Embryology Day: Know the world of baby scientists, and how this can impact the success rate of your IV.. - ETHealthWorld - August 5th, 2024 [August 5th, 2024]
- ESHRE Ferti Job Hub: A New Initiative for Employers and Job Seekers in Human Reproduction and Embryology - ESHRE - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Understanding Synthetic Embryology and Its Implications for Healthcare - Medriva - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- These are the six things to think about before freezing your eggs - Daily Mail - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- Merck Foundation CEO and Liberia First Lady Report the Impact of Their Long-Term Partnership to Transform Patient Care in Liberia - Devdiscourse - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- USask researcher aims to revolutionize human-assisted reproduction - USask News - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- IVF works for the lucky few. After a decade, I finally realised I wasnt one of them - The Guardian - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- When your mother's not your mother and the problems of ... - The Tablet - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- On World Veterinary Day Let us Celebrate the Diversity of the Noble ... - Rising Kashmir - May 5th, 2023 [May 5th, 2023]
- Can exercise help with Endometriosis? - EchoLive.ie - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Fertility expert shares the seven things you need to know before freezing your eggs - The Mirror - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Arlington and Alexandria Bring Home the 4-H Ribbons - Virginia Connection Newspapers - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- PINNACLE FERTILITY ANNOUNCES THE PROMOTION OF BETH ... - PR Newswire - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Delay in early development of the embryo associated with likelihood of miscarriage - News-Medical.Net - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Rumi Scientific Appoints Allen A. Fienberg, Ph.D., as Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of the Board of - EIN News - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority consults on proposed ... - Solicitors Journal - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Abortion may be legal in Argentina but women still face major obstacles - BBC - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Scientists urge pregnant women to avoid using plastic bottles - Daily Mail - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Precongress courses at ESHRE23 characterised by practicality and ... - ESHRE - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Couple's Child Has Deadly Cancer Gene Thanks to IVF Clinic's ... - The Daily Beast - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Three-parent baby technique could create babies at risk of severe disease - MIT Technology Review - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- UK ministers urged to consider changing law to allow genome editing of human embryos: Report - WION - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Surrogacy: the strict approach to consent - Lexology - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- In politics, there's no such thing as private faith - The Times - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Delayed motherhood: Why more women are opting to freeze their ... - Eve Magazine - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- National Science Day & Rare Disease Day Observed At ILS ... - Ommcom News - March 6th, 2023 [March 6th, 2023]
- Comparative Embryology - Developmental Biology - NCBI Bookshelf - October 20th, 2022 [October 20th, 2022]
- A guided route - The Hindu - October 20th, 2022 [October 20th, 2022]
- How infertility drove me into reproductive medicine | The Guardian Nigeria News - Nigeria and World News Guardian Woman - Guardian Nigeria - October 20th, 2022 [October 20th, 2022]
- Quran and the Modern Science - Brighter Kashmir - October 3rd, 2022 [October 3rd, 2022]
- Jehangir Hospital launches state of the art IVF centre with best facilities - Devdiscourse - October 3rd, 2022 [October 3rd, 2022]
- Dead fish breathes new life into the evolutionary origin of fins and limbs - EurekAlert - October 3rd, 2022 [October 3rd, 2022]
- Merck Foundation Together with African First Ladies Mark 'World Heart Day 2022' - The Week - October 3rd, 2022 [October 3rd, 2022]
- The LA Times gets abortion and the Church dramatically wrong - Angelus News - October 3rd, 2022 [October 3rd, 2022]
- THE CASE FOR INVAGINATION #4 Comes to The Mass Building - Broadway World - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Improving medical student recruitment into neurosurgery through teaching reform - BMC Medical Education - BMC Medical Education - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Embryology: Definition & Development Stages - Study.com - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Embryology, Ear - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Fertility law and regulation need to changehere's how it could happen - The BMJ - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Indiana Family Health Council pushes for more sex ed after abortion ban - WTHR - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Letter writer disturbed by abortion support | Letters to the Editor | thebrunswicknews.com - Brunswick News - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- How spilled coffee inspired a Boston sperm-testing startup - The Boston Globe - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Merck Foundation CEO Acknowledged Zimbabwe First Lady's Efforts as Ambassador of More than a Mother to Build Healthcare Capacity, Break Infertility S... - August 24th, 2022 [August 24th, 2022]
- Pig Development - Embryology - UNSW Sites - August 16th, 2022 [August 16th, 2022]
- Master of Clinical Embryology - Study at Monash University - August 16th, 2022 [August 16th, 2022]
- Letter: The inconvenient science of embryology - INFORUM - August 16th, 2022 [August 16th, 2022]
- Letters to the Editor August 13, 2022 | The Citizen - Ortonville Citizen - August 16th, 2022 [August 16th, 2022]
- Scientists Are Learning How to Help Coral Reefs Save Themselves - AAAS - August 16th, 2022 [August 16th, 2022]
- Hypospadias: A Comprehensive Review Including Its Embryology, Etiology and Surgical Techniques - Cureus - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Woman, 20, jailed in UK for taking abortion pills when abusive partner got her pregnant - The Mirror - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Woman gives birth to triplets with two-year age gaps between them - The Independent - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- The earliest segmental sternum in a Permian synapsid and its implications for the evolution of mammalian locomotion and ventilation | Scientific... - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Egg donors in the UK: What it's actually like donating your eggs - Cosmopolitan UK - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Elon Musks Babies Were Conceived Via IVF And Surrogacy - Is It The Future Of Reproduction? - Forbes - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Handful of Tories declare themselves as candidates to replace Johnson - Morning Star Online - July 15th, 2022 [July 15th, 2022]
- Y Combinator-Backed Lilia Launches A More Convenient And Affordable Egg Freezing Offering Built For The Millennial Women - Forbes - July 15th, 2022 [July 15th, 2022]
- The End of the Beginning of the End of Abortion | Hadley Arkes - First Things - June 25th, 2022 [June 25th, 2022]
- Widower wins right to have baby using embryo created with his late wife - The Guardian - June 25th, 2022 [June 25th, 2022]
- How Does Comparative Embryology Support the Theory of Evolution? - June 25th, 2022 [June 25th, 2022]
- IVF: Three key requirements before you can have fertility treatment on the NHS - Express - June 25th, 2022 [June 25th, 2022]
- Harry Potter's World Similar to the Magic of Endocrinology - Medscape - June 25th, 2022 [June 25th, 2022]
- L'Oral-UNESCO For Women in Science International Awards 2022 - Benzinga - Benzinga - June 7th, 2022 [June 7th, 2022]
- Women, Witches, and Abortion: A Misguided Attack on Justice Alito - Public Discourse - June 7th, 2022 [June 7th, 2022]
- Updates to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology (HFE) Act - Lexology - May 6th, 2022 [May 6th, 2022]
- Widower in High Court fight over use of embryo created after IVF treatment - Forres Gazette - May 6th, 2022 [May 6th, 2022]
- Australia Moves Ahead Cautiously With '3-Parent IVF' - WIRED - May 6th, 2022 [May 6th, 2022]
- I donated sperm to father 47 kids but women don't want to date me - New York Post - May 6th, 2022 [May 6th, 2022]
- The Virtual Human Embryo - EHD - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- Embryology Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- Buyer Beware: IVF Damages and the Value of Life - American Council on Science and Health - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- The Stark Reality of Parents' COVID Deaths Grandparents Step In - The Washington Informer - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- IVF Add-Ons: Why You Should Be Cautious Of These Expensive Procedures - SheThePeople - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- Attitude And Perception Of Medical Students Towards Histolog | AMEP - Dove Medical Press - April 23rd, 2022 [April 23rd, 2022]
- Science in the Neighborhood Public Lecture Dr. Alexandria Forbes - Carnegie Institution for Science - April 9th, 2022 [April 9th, 2022]
- Scots mum's heartbreak as UK law stops teen daughter moving to America to join her family - Daily Record - April 9th, 2022 [April 9th, 2022]
- In Vitro Fertilization Market Analysis by Production, Consumption and Competitive Analysis Till 2028 Mianeh - Mianeh - April 9th, 2022 [April 9th, 2022]
- Embryology - Embryogenesis, Human Development and Stages ... - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Frozen Embryos: Who Gets Them? Who Keeps Them? Who Destroys Them? And When? - American Council on Science and Health - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- New muscle layer discovered on the human jaw - The Indian Express - December 28th, 2021 [December 28th, 2021]
- Demystifying IVF: Everything You Need To Know (Including Chances Of Success) - Momtastic - December 16th, 2021 [December 16th, 2021]