Photo: Federic J. Brown/AFP via Getty Images
What if it never really ends, just recedes?
There are, at the moment, a number of encouraging signs about the near-term course of things: Caseloads and hospitalizations are falling dramatically, perhaps as a sign of seasonal effects turning a corner; vaccine deployment, while still suboptimal, is improved from a month ago; there has been good news about additional vaccines, with AstraZeneca (already approved in the U.K. but facing an FDA roadblock here) reporting fantastic results against severe disease; and vaccine shipments are said to on the way, with Novavax promising 100 million American doses by the spring.
A few months ago, these developments might have suggested the true endgame of the pandemic was in sightand indeed the likely vaccination of 100 million or more by late spring does suggest a dramatic change in the countrys experience of the disease, with those vaccinated feeling safe from hospitalization and death and the disease in retreat. But thanks to a combination of higher herd-immunity estimates, stubbornly high vaccine hesitancy, and the arrival of new coronavirus variants that render existing vaccines less effective, the second year of the American pandemic is beginning to look less like a page-turning, book-slammed-shut bang and more like a long and indefinite whimpering into the future in which many are protected but the disease, undefeated, still circulates, perhaps forever. That the coronavirus would become endemic, like the common cold, has always been one possible outcome, though less appealing than true elimination. The arrival of new variants has made that kind of near-term future, with enduring reservoirs of virus throughout the country, seem less appealing still.
This is, at base, a matter of the math of herd immunity whether the vaccines we have, combined with the natural protection already acquired through disease exposure, can produce sufficient population-level immunity that the coronavirus actually dies away. Most of the vaccine trials were focused on reduction of severe disease, and so we do not yet have a clear sense of how effective they will be in stopping transmissionthough most experts believe they will put a pretty big dent in caseloads. How big? In December, Harvards Marc Lipsitch estimated that the current bundle of vaccines would likely prove between 50 and 70 percent effective against transmission. What does that mean in terms of herd immunity? A sort of median estimate of the natural reproduction rate (or R0) for the classic COVID-19 strain is around 3 on average, each person infected in a totally unexposed population would infect three others. Assuming an R0 of 3 yields an estimated herd-immunity threshold of 67 percent exposure, which, Bloombergs Justin Fox points out, would require between 96 percent and 134 percent of the population be vaccinated to achieve herd immunity.At the end of last year, Anthony Fauci somewhat controversially revised his own estimate of the threshold of herd immunity, first from between 60 and 70 percent to 70, 75 percent, then to 75, 80, 85 percent, then to 80-plus percent, and then all the way to 90 percent. Mathematically, you simply cannot achieve 90 percent protection from a vaccine that offers even 70 percent protection, let alone 50 percent, and while the vaccines might somewhat outperform Lipsitchs back-of-the-envelope calculations, the new variants are driving their efficacy in the other direction, pushing herd immunity even further out of reach. Perhaps the vaccines will surprise us, offering more protection against transmission than has been expectedand in this goal the country may be aided by the naturally lower rates of transmission among the very young. A bit more than a quarter of the country has already been exposed to the virus, which means we may already have 80 million or more Americans with protection. But that is only a true floor on which to add additional immunity through vaccination if none of those previously infected line up to get shotsand since the majority of them probably dont even know they had the disease in the first place, and no effort is being made to target vaccine doses to the un-exposed, the contribution of those 80 million towards herd immunity is likely to be somewhat smaller than their numbers suggest.
Technically, of course, even vaccinating 96 percent of the country would be doable, though almost certainly it would take the U.S. into 2022 to achieve it. But the challenge grows steeper when you turn from the abstractions of math to the much messier world of human behavior. While it is certainly likely that vaccine resistance will gradually shrink as more and more Americans safely receive shots, with infection rates beginning to fall as a result, the scale of present-tense skepticism is an immense roadblock. According to a large Kaiser Family Foundation poll published in December, only 41 percent of Americans say they will definitely agree to be vaccinated, with another 30 percent saying they probably will, 12 percent saying probably not, and 15 percent saying definitely not. That gives a rough ceiling of 85 percent of the American population signaling at least some openness to vaccination, less than Faucis estimate of threshold of 90 percent needed for herd immunity (though, presumably, some of the already-infected could help close that gap). And of course certain groups are more skeptical than others in rural America, Kaiser found, only 64 percent would definitely or probably take the vaccine and 35 percent probably or definitely wouldnt. More recently, an eye-opening report by the CDC suggested that among those working at nursing homes and other long-term-care facilities, only 37 percent agreed to a first dose.
And then there are the variants, which seem already to be reducing the efficacy of our existing batch of vaccines with presumably more variants to come. Already, what has been called the U.K. strain seems to have picked up a new mutation first observed in the South African and Brazilian strains, for instance, which may further reduce the effectiveness of vaccines and natural immune protection. And in most of the world, limited genetic surveillance of the disease means we are probably missing some new variants of the disease. Of course, it is important to remember that rendering existing vaccines less effective is not the same thing as rendering them ineffectiveand that even with reduced efficacy, the vaccines we have do seem to offer meaningful population-level protection against the new variants. Already many of the manufacturers are working on retooling their products to offer additional protection against the new strains indeed, this ability to tweak the existing vaccine platforms has been one big selling point of the new class of vaccines produced for the first time, with breathtaking speed, in this pandemic. But at least according to initial reports, those tweaked vaccines wont be available until 2022 almost a year from the arrival of this group of variants.
This is not to say that the brief window of vaccine optimism will yield only to a future of eternal, or even periodic, lockdown. Things are going to get a lot better, and probably pretty quickly. The vaccines are very effective in protecting against severe disease, at least when caused by the classic strain, which means that anyone who receives them will likely feel safe and protected from the scariest outcomes again, at least against the classic strain. Herd immunity is not binary, which means that well before its threshold is reached, the spread of the disease will begin to slow, perhaps even precipitously in fact, there is some hope that we are already beginning to see such population exposure bending the curve of cases downward. And some mathematical modelers have long argued that calculations of herd-immunity thresholds based simply on R0, like Faucis, are crude overestimates, overlooking the superspreader dynamics of the disease (whereby the vast majority of new infections are produced from a tiny minority of cases and the median sick person doesnt infect anyone else at all). But many of them have been making those arguments since the beginning of the pandemic, suggesting that herd immunity was just around the corner in communities and countries that then saw large second and third waves and in fact there have been terrible subsequent waves even in places, like Brazils Manaus, estimated to have had much higher levels of exposure (in the case of Manaus, exposure was estimated at 76 percent, in the vicinity of most estimated herd-immunity thresholds). Seasonal effects may help quite a lot, suppressing the disease for roughly three-quarters of the year.
But it does mean that what has long been the dream of most Americans enduring the pandemic a point at which all of this is over, with COVID-19 as much a historical artifact for us as, say, SARS is in East Asia may never come to pass precisely as imagined. Instead, in the medium term and perhaps even the long term, a likelier endgame is one in which large portions of the population are protected, from at least severe disease produced by at least some variants, but, with immunity falling short of the herd threshold, the disease continues to circulate infecting even some of those whove been vaccinated, threatening the lives of those who havent, and continuing to evolve, perhaps in some scary ways. For most of those whove received a vaccine, the disease will fade into the background, joining the ranks of other endemic diseases, but as a social fact the coronavirus will nevertheless remain.
What will that world look like? In Denmark, they are already planning on issuing immunity passports, which would allow those whove been vaccinated to travel and socialize and do business in ways that others still cant a sort of immunity apartheid system of the kind that many warned about at the beginning of the pandemic but appears more and more difficult to avoid and that may ultimately persuade some number of vaccine skeptics to receive doses after all. There could also be harder measures taken, with companies requiring vaccine compliance from employees or even a national vaccine mandate though each of these measures would run up against health-privacy protections in the U.S., where even masking regulations have proved difficult to enforce. The fate of those measures of vigilance is unclear, too if less than half of nursing-home workers are vaccinated, will long-term-care residents and staff be required both to mask up and to social distance in an ongoing way, as they have for the last year, in circumstances described as solitary confinement, which may have already produced a mental-health crisis? Especially in places with low vaccination rates, schools may deploy temperature checks and rapid spit-tests or may disregard those protocols and risk sporadic outbreaks. And any time a new strain arises, in the American reservoir or abroad, there may be renewed panic and vigilance with even already-vaccinated people waiting those many months it will take to roll out a tweaked vaccine to feel truly safe again.
Daily news about the politics, business, and technology shaping our world.
Read more:
What If Herd Immunity Is Out of Reach? - New York Magazine
- The Impact of AI on Human Behavior: Insights and Implications - iTMunch - January 23rd, 2025 [January 23rd, 2025]
- Disturbing Wildlife Isnt Fun: IFS Parveen Kaswan Raises Concern Over Human Behavior in Viral Clip - Indian Masterminds - January 15th, 2025 [January 15th, 2025]
- The interplay of time and space in human behavior: a sociological perspective on the TSCH model - Nature.com - January 1st, 2025 [January 1st, 2025]
- Thinking Slowly: The Paradoxical Slowness of Human Behavior - Caltech - December 23rd, 2024 [December 23rd, 2024]
- From smog to crime: How air pollution is shaping human behavior and public safety - The Times of India - December 9th, 2024 [December 9th, 2024]
- The Smell Of Death Has A Strange Influence On Human Behavior - IFLScience - October 26th, 2024 [October 26th, 2024]
- "WEIRD" in psychology literature oversimplifies the global diversity of human behavior. - Psychology Today - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Scientists issue warning about increasingly alarming whale behavior due to human activity - Orcasonian - September 23rd, 2024 [September 23rd, 2024]
- Does AI adoption call for a change in human behavior? - Fast Company - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Dogs can smell human stress and it alters their own behavior, study reveals - New York Post - July 26th, 2024 [July 26th, 2024]
- Trajectories of brain and behaviour development in the womb, at birth and through infancy - Nature.com - June 18th, 2024 [June 18th, 2024]
- AI model predicts human behavior from our poor decision-making - Big Think - June 18th, 2024 [June 18th, 2024]
- ZkSync defends Sybil measures as Binance offers own ZK token airdrop - TradingView - June 18th, 2024 [June 18th, 2024]
- On TikTok, Goldendoodles Are People Trapped in Dog Bodies - The New York Times - June 18th, 2024 [June 18th, 2024]
- 10 things only introverts find irritating, according to psychology - Hack Spirit - June 18th, 2024 [June 18th, 2024]
- 32 animals that act weirdly human sometimes - Livescience.com - May 24th, 2024 [May 24th, 2024]
- NBC Is Using Animals To Push The LGBT Agenda. Here Are 5 Abhorrent Animal Behaviors Humans Shouldn't Emulate - The Daily Wire - May 24th, 2024 [May 24th, 2024]
- New study examines the dynamics of adaptive autonomy in human volition and behavior - PsyPost - May 24th, 2024 [May 24th, 2024]
- 30000 years of history reveals that hard times boost human societies' resilience - Livescience.com - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes Actors Had Trouble Reverting Back to Human - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- The need to feel safe is a core driver of human behavior. - Psychology Today - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- AI learned how to sway humans by watching a cooperative cooking game - Science News Magazine - March 29th, 2024 [March 29th, 2024]
- We can't combat climate change without changing minds. This psychology class explores how. - Northeastern University - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Bees Reveal a Human-Like Collective Intelligence We Never Knew Existed - ScienceAlert - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Franciscan AI expert warns of technology becoming a 'pseudo-religion' - Detroit Catholic - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Freshwater resources at risk thanks to human behavior - messenger-inquirer - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Astrocytes Play Critical Role in Regulating Behavior - Neuroscience News - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Freshwater resources at risk thanks to human behavior - Sunnyside Sun - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Freshwater resources at risk thanks to human behavior - Blue Mountain Eagle - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- 7 Books on Human Behavior - Times Now - March 11th, 2024 [March 11th, 2024]
- Euphemisms increasingly used to soften behavior that would be questionable in direct language - Norfolk Daily News - February 29th, 2024 [February 29th, 2024]
- Linking environmental influences, genetic research to address concerns of genetic determinism of human behavior - Phys.org - February 29th, 2024 [February 29th, 2024]
- Emerson's Insight: Navigating the Three Fundamental Desires of Human Nature - The Good Men Project - February 29th, 2024 [February 29th, 2024]
- Dogs can recognize a bad person and there's science to prove it. - GOOD - February 29th, 2024 [February 29th, 2024]
- What Is Organizational Behavior? Everything You Need To Know - MarketWatch - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Overcoming 'Otherness' in Scientific Research Commentary in Nature Human Behavior USA - English - USA - PR Newswire - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- "Reichman University's behavioral economics program: Navigating human be - The Jerusalem Post - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Of trees, symbols of humankind, on Tu BShevat - The Jewish Star - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Tapping Into The Power Of Positive Psychology With Acclaimed Expert Niyc Pidgeon - GirlTalkHQ - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Don't just make resolutions, 'be the architect of your future self,' says Stanford-trained human behavior expert - CNBC - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Never happy? Humans tend to imagine how life could be better : Short Wave - NPR - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- People who feel unhappy but hide it well usually exhibit these 9 behaviors - Hack Spirit - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- If you display these 9 behaviors, you're being passive aggressive without realizing it - Hack Spirit - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Men who are relationship-oriented by nature usually display these 9 behaviors - Hack Spirit - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- A look at the curious 'winter break' behavior of ChatGPT-4 - ReadWrite - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Neuroscience and Behavior Major (B.S.) | College of Liberal Arts - UNH's College of Liberal Arts - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- The positive health effects of prosocial behaviors | News | Harvard ... - HSPH News - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- The valuable link between succession planning and skills - Human Resource Executive - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Okinawa's ants show reduced seasonal behavior in areas with more human development - Phys.org - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- How humans use their sense of smell to find their way | Penn Today - Penn Today - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Wrestling With Evil in the World, or Is It Something Else? - Psychiatric Times - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Shimmying like electric fish is a universal movement across species - Earth.com - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Why do dogs get the zoomies? - Care.com - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- How Stuart Robinson's misconduct went overlooked for years - Washington Square News - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Whatchamacolumn: Homeless camps back in the news - News-Register - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Stunted Growth in Infants Reshapes Brain Function and Cognitive ... - Neuroscience News - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Social medias role in modeling human behavior, societies - kuwaittimes - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- The gift of reformation - Living Lutheran - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- After pandemic, birds are surprisingly becoming less fearful of humans - Study Finds - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Nick Treglia: The trouble with fairness and the search for truth - 1819 News - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Science has an answer for why people still wave on Zoom - Press Herald - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Orcas are learning terrifying new behaviors. Are they getting smarter? - Livescience.com - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Augmenting the Regulatory Worker: Are We Making Them Better or ... - BioSpace - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- What "The Creator", a film about the future, tells us about the present - InCyber - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- WashU Expert: Some parasites turn hosts into 'zombies' - The ... - Washington University in St. Louis - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Is secondhand smoke from vapes less toxic than from traditional ... - Missouri S&T News and Research - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- How apocalyptic cults use psychological tricks to brainwash their ... - Big Think - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Human action pushing the world closer to environmental tipping ... - Morung Express - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- What We Get When We Give | Harvard Medicine Magazine - Harvard University - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Psychological Anime: 12 Series You Should Watch - But Why Tho? - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- Roosters May Recognize Their Reflections in Mirrors, Study Suggests - Smithsonian Magazine - October 27th, 2023 [October 27th, 2023]
- June 30 Zodiac: Sign, Traits, Compatibility and More - AZ Animals - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Indiana's Funding Ban for Kinsey Sex-Research Institute Threatens ... - The Chronicle of Higher Education - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Have AI Chatbots Developed Theory of Mind? What We Do and Do ... - The New York Times - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Scoop: Coming Up on a New Episode of HOUSEBROKEN on FOX ... - Broadway World - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Here's five fall 2023 classes to fire up your bookbag - Duke Chronicle - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- McDonald: Aspen's like living in a 'Pullman town' - The Aspen Times - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Children Who Are Exposed to Awe-Inspiring Art Are More Likely to Become Generous, Empathic Adults, a New Study Says - artnet News - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- DataDome Raises Another $42M to Prevent Bot Attacks in Real ... - AlleyWatch - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Observing group-living animals with drones may help us understand ... - Innovation Origins - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]