Home Articles Against Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Physicians Letter to His Legislator
The committee hearings begin today, January 25, 2024, on the End-of-Life Option Act (SF 1813/HF 1930). If passed, this bill would allow residents in Minnesota access to physician-assisted suicides.
To whom it may concern:
My name is Tod Worner, and I am a practicing internal medicine physician in the Minneapolis area. I live in Plymouth, MN, and vote in District 43A. I am opposed to the proposed bill legalizing physician-assisted suicide.
I find myself in a curious position. As a physician who has spent decades trying to heal patients, I find myself imploring my duly elected representatives not to usher in the most seismic cultural and ethical transformation in modern medical practicethe act of taking life instead of comforting or saving it.
As you know, there are currently ten states (to date) in which physician-assisted suicide is legalized (California, Colorado, Oregon, Vermont, New Mexico, Maine, New Jersey, New Mexico, Hawaii, and Washington) and Washington, D.C. Montana has legalized it by court ruling. Furthermore, a number of them have weakened residency requirements so as to encourage a grim form of medical suicide tourism. Physician-assisted suicide is also legalized (to date) in Canada, Belgium, Luxembourg, Spain, Germany, Switzerland, and the Netherlands. Pediatric euthanasia has already been carried out in Belgium, the Netherlands, and is being pursued by interest groups and legislators in Canada, among other locales. And now, alas, physician-assisted suicide is, once again, knocking on Minnesotas door.
What are we becoming? What does it mean to heal?
Lest we find ourselves reassured by a burgeoning tendency to legalize this dark practice, let me borrow from Mark Twain when he said, Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect.
Indeed.
George Orwell once sighed, We have now sunk to a depth at which restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men.
And so let me begin.
As a physician,mydaily practice is to heal the sick and prevent disease. In so doing, I try to uphold thedignity of eachpatienttreating them with respect while working in partnership to achieve a rich quality in concertwith a reasonable quantity of life. Of course, I recognizethe value of autonomy to afford patient choice, but that means a choice insofar as it simultaneously comports with the practice of safe, sound, and ethical medicine. To be sure, patient choice must be just and the care they receive beneficent, but that same choice must notby slippery euphemism and crafty manipulation, emotional appeal and legal maneuveringsI repeat, must not compel a physician to commit a maleficent act, especially one that runs against centuries of common law and customs, statutory law and social contract, as well as the sacred conscience and sound judgment of the physician in the relationship.
So what does this mean when it comes to physician-assisted suicide?
In a few words, it means that a patient has many rights, but he does not have the right to demand that I assist him in killing himselfany more than he can demand I prescribe himunnecessary narcotics, unwarranted antibiotics, or ill-considered surgery. To demand these measures indiscriminately would be to violate the dignity of the patient with risky (or fatal) outcomes as well as compromise my dignity (and conscience) as a trained and seasoned physician to thoughtfully consider the best care for the patient.
That is why, as a physician, I am opposed to physician-assisted suicide. Furthermore, allow me to offer these threearguments against this concerning practice:
When Julius Caesar illegally ledhis army into Italy in defiance of the Roman Senate, he had topass through a river known as the Rubicon, which separatedItaly from the province of Gaul. When he crossed the Rubicon and became a traitor to his state, he uttered the die is cast and knew there was no going back. Once medicine has transformed itself from a vocation whose first and only priority is to heal and comfort into a profession that is willing to kill, we will have crossed the Rubicon. We will have wandered away from the oath to First, do no harm and to give no deadly medicine to any one if asked, nor suggest any such counsel. Henceforth, the consequences would be both unintended and grave to patients, physicians, and society. We must stop, once again, and reconsider just what it means to be physicians, to be healers. And we must remember what it means to be human. If we forget the fundamental, uncompromising, and ineradicable value intrinsic to human life, can we still call ourselves physicians?
The popular press, judicial activists, and enterprising legislators have grown increasingly sympathetic to the physician-assisted suicide movement. As such, anecdote after anecdote highlight people with grave medical maladies offering poignant interviews or writing last letters articulating their sincere fears of unremitting pain and incomparable suffering. They see only two alternatives: one is to suffer a prolonged, painful, and humiliating death, while the other is to proactively commit dignified suicide under the sympathetic eyes of their physician. Thats it. What is striking, however, is how little conversation there is about Palliative Care and Hospice.
Designed fully around the notion of providing dignity, autonomy, and symptom management in the face of terminal illness, Palliative Care and Hospice provide extraordinary end-of-life care to the very people who feel they have no fate but suffering ahead. These physicians and clinicians are well-trained and deeply committed to the care of those very patients that physician-assisted suicide advocates specifically target. In over two decades of practicing internal medicine, I have had a number of patients enroll in these services. I have yet to find one family who didnt gratefully describe the profound dignity, loving kindness, and tender management of pain, anxiety, and symptoms they witnessed in the waning days of their loved ones life. Surely, that is not to say that there cant be patients with symptoms that could be difficult to manage. But does that mean that we should then move to a widespread, systemic legalization of physician-assisted killing? With the oft untapped and unrecognized virtues of Palliative Care and Hospice, I think we are rushing to providea dangerous solution desperately in search of a problem.
Invariably, when legislation such as physician-assisted suicide is considered, concerns are raised about the slippery slopethat is, the unintended consequences and abuses that result from permitting such a policy at all. Enlightened minds that know better shake their heads and tut-tut that our concernsare overreactions. We would have safeguards against abuses, we are told, We would craft laws protecting minors or the mentally ill or the demented or the handicapped or others without terminal illness from ever being considered for physician-assisted suicide. It would be a rare event. Economics (a patients draining resources, the burden on the medical system) would never be a factor in a merciful act devoted to preserving the dignity of the individual.
2024 Lenten Gospel Reflections
To be sure, all of these reassuring arguments sound good and have been made in countries and states that have legalized physician-assisted suicide. And, too often, they have been wrong. People with mental illness and no terminal disease have been allowed to die. Minors in Belgium and the Netherlands have died under this policy. Physicians have been more aggressive in utilizing this option in the ill, but not terminally ill. Patients have reported fear of being hospitalized lest they become victims to a crusading doctors zeal. Exploding costs for end-of-life care and budgets groaning under the weight of the perpetually ill have a conscious or unconscious impact on a system where physician-assisted suicide is an option.
As far as being rare, according to the BMJs Journal of Medical Ethics (10/27/2023), there was an over sixteen-fold increase in physician-assisted suicide cases in Oregon from 1997 to 2022 while there was a drop in coinciding psychiatric assessments (evaluating the patients emotional state for such a decision) from 31.1% to 1.1%. The author of the paper, David Albert Jones, concludes, We now have twenty-five years of data from Oregon and data from an increasing number of other states with similar laws. However, the more we know, the less reassuring the Oregon model of assisted suicide seems to be. Nonetheless, those promoting this law will reassure us. Weve thought of these concerns and, if need be, we will enact further laws to protect patients from abuse. To this reasoning, I would ask, How will the small laws protect us, when the big law (against physician-assisted suicide) has been able to fall? When it comes to the institutionalization of physician-assisted suicide, mark my words, telling us that everything will be okay is a misguided, if not dangerous, philosophy.
For the last twenty-four years, it has been an honor and privilege to practice internal medicine. I love my patients, enjoy my colleagues, and cherish my calling. But that calling will fundamentally change if we devolve from a vocation that heals to a vocation that kills.
Most of what I have written today in opposition to physician-assisted suicide is fairly obvious. And I am here, simply and sadly, to restate it.
In having to do so, it is hard not to ask,What are we becoming? What does it mean to heal?
Heaven help us if we dont know the answer.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Tod Worner, MD
More here:
Against Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Physicians Letter to His Legislator - Word on Fire
- What it's like in internal medicine: Shadowing Dr. Graham - American Medical Association - December 9th, 2024 [December 9th, 2024]
- Grants Awarded to the Department of Internal Medicine (December 2024) - Yale School of Medicine - December 9th, 2024 [December 9th, 2024]
- UPMC plans to wind down internal medicine residency at UPMC McKeesport - The Business Journals - November 28th, 2024 [November 28th, 2024]
- Marzena Odorczuk, MD of Internal Medicine Of Totowa Awarded As 2024 NJ Top Doc - EIN News - November 12th, 2024 [November 12th, 2024]
- From residency to leadership: the evolution of internal medicine [PODCAST] - Kevin MD - October 13th, 2024 [October 13th, 2024]
- Internal Medicine residency launched at MUSC Health Florence Medical Center - Medical University of South Carolina - October 2nd, 2024 [October 2nd, 2024]
- Statesville Internal Medicine Moving to Bryant Street - Iredell Health System - September 15th, 2024 [September 15th, 2024]
- Medical students honor Internal Medicine faculty, fellows they aspire to emulate - UT Southwestern - September 15th, 2024 [September 15th, 2024]
- Grants Awarded to the Department of Internal Medicine (September 2024) - Yale School of Medicine - September 15th, 2024 [September 15th, 2024]
- Yale Internal Medicine Reflects on Past 10 Years in New Report - Yale School of Medicine - September 15th, 2024 [September 15th, 2024]
- Meet ABIMs new leader: The future is bright for internal medicine - Medical Economics - September 2nd, 2024 [September 2nd, 2024]
- Should neonatal-perinatal medicine move to two-year fellowships? | Journal of Perinatology - Nature.com - June 9th, 2024 [June 9th, 2024]
- Vigorous exercise may preserve cognition in high-risk patients with hypertension - EurekAlert - June 9th, 2024 [June 9th, 2024]
- Studying the effects of probiotics for idiopathic epilepsy - DVM 360 - June 9th, 2024 [June 9th, 2024]
- Pride Celebrated at UConn Health - UConn Today - University of Connecticut - June 9th, 2024 [June 9th, 2024]
- Residents and Faculty Shine at Internal Medicine Annual Meeting - Washington State University - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Opinion | Smoking Isn't the Only Source of Nicotine Addiction in Town - Medpage Today - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Benefis gets approval for Internal Medicine residency program - KRTV NEWS Great Falls - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- A Mother's Encouragement and a Husband-Wife Doctor Team Set the Stage for a Career in Hematologic Oncology - The ASCO Post - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Local doctor to share new lifestyle health techniques with Longboaters - Your Observer - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Marquis Who's Who Honors H. Kenneth Fisher, MD, for Expertise in Medicine - 24-7 Press Release - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Clinical Score Predicts Recovery From Dialysis Dependent Acute Kidney Injury - MedicalResearch.com - June 1st, 2024 [June 1st, 2024]
- Interdisciplinary Curriculum Boosts Women's Health and Gender-Affirming Care in Internal Medicine Residency - Yale School of Medicine - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- David Jerome Becker Obituary - - Hartford Courant - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Med students earn awards as part of Cape Fear Research Symposium - News | Campbell University - Campbell University News - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Rowan University graduate inspired to pursue internal medicine after cancer journey - CBS Philly - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- UChicago Medicine residents unionize in landslide election | Evening Digest | hpherald.com - Hyde Park Herald - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- McKee Names New Head of Health, 5th Director in Three Years - GoLocalProv - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- An Internal Medicine Physician & Aesthetic Specialist's Best Tips | mindbodygreen - mindbodygreen - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Health-related quality of life assessment tool for cats with hyperthyroidism - DVM 360 - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Finding the Right Approach to Treating Asthma < Yale School of Medicine - Yale School of Medicine - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Stigmatizing Language Common in Clinical Notes for Patients With SUD - Medpage Today - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Patrick Hemming, MD: Depression, Anxiety Treatment by the Internal Medicine Physician - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- UConn Health's Dr. Rebecca Andrews Takes on New National Role - UConn Today - University of Connecticut - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Women are less likely to die when treated by female doctors, study suggests - Yahoo! Voices - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Are female doctors the key to keeping patients alive longer? - - Study Finds - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Anne Thorndike, MD, MPH: Discussing Treatment Approaches for Patients with Obesity - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Prolonged Medical Fasting May Benefit Pain Symptoms in Fibromyalgia - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Discussing Ways to Approach Improving Obesity Care with Melanie Jay, MD - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Timothy Wilt, MD, MPH: Discussing Colorectal Cancer Screening Options Recommended by ACP - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- 'Sluggish' Hospital Uptake of Newer Antibiotics for Gram-Negative Infections - Medpage Today - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Elizabeth Cerceo, MD, on How to Address Health Care's Impact on Climate Change - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Melanie Jay, MD: Advancing Equitable Approaches to Improve Obesity Care - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- American College of Physicians issues clinical recommendations for newer pharmacological treatments of adults with ... - InvestorsObserver - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Scientists unveil new remote-controlled 'pillbot' a microrobot that you can swallow for early disease detection - Good Good Good - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- What We Would Be If We Weren't Doctors - Medpage Today - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Dual-Tasking: Spotlighting the Impacts on Individuals with Dementia - MD Magazine - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- Here Are The Suggestions Of Internal Medicine Specialist Doctors So That The Body Is Healthy After Eid - VOI English - April 23rd, 2024 [April 23rd, 2024]
- New Professors in the Department of Internal Medicine - Yale School of Medicine - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Nephrologist Choudhry now part of GGH team | Health | fltimes.com - Finger Lakes Times - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Department of Internal Medicine Grand Rounds - The University of Arizona College of Medicine Phoenix - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- McLaren Port Huron to launch internal medicine resident physician program - The Times Herald - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Implementation and Evaluation of a Pilot Narrative Medicine Curriculum for Internal Medicine Residents - Cureus - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Facing doctor shortage, BayCare to train hundreds more in Tampa Bay - Tampa Bay Times - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- NYU Langone Health in the NewsThursday, February 1, 2024 - NYU Langone Health - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Dr. Ben Gallagher Receives SGIM Northeast Region's Award for Excellence in Clinician Education - Yale School of Medicine - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Tulsa Doctor Shares 7 Steps To A Healthier Heart - News On 6 - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Perceptions of X+Y Scheduling Among Combined Internal Medicine-Pediatrics Residency Trainees: A Qualitative ... - Cureus - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Taskforce works to end racialized differences in medical education and practice - Wayne State University - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Toms River Internal Medicine Specialist, Dr. Prabhat Sinha Awarded As NJ Top Doc - EIN News - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Medical Mystery Case: What Landed This Pregnant Woman in the Hospital? - Medpage Today - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- NYU Langone Health in the NewsWednesday, December 27, 2023 - NYU Langone Health - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Internal Medicine Specialist Discusses Weight-Loss Medication - News On 6 - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Adoption of Internal Medicine Milestone Ratings and Changes in Bias Against Black, Latino, and Asian Internal ... - Annals of Internal Medicine - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Beebe welcomes award-winning infectious disease specialist - CapeGazette.com - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- People rally around doctor who refused to provide medical assistance on flight for a valid reason - Upworthy - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Adventist Health Tillamook welcomes new top Internal Medicine Provider - Tillamook Headlight-Herald - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Perceived Preparedness of Internal Medicine Interns for Residency and the Value of Transition to Residency Courses - Cureus - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Remembering Vice Adm. Michael Cowan, the 34th Surgeon General of Navy Medicine (2001-2004) - American Military News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Enhancing the Comprehensive Integration of General Medicine Education in Rural Japan: A Thematic Analysis - Cureus - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- James Murray named head doctor at Confluence Health - Source ONE News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- The Analysis of Job Satisfaction of Health Practitioners in Saudi Arabia: Determinants and Strategic Recommendations ... - Cureus - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Top docs of 2023and what it takes to be one - MD Linx - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Another Medical Society Turns Up the Heat on MOC - Medpage Today - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- SMH Addiction and Internal Medicine Clinic caring for the whole ... - Sheridan Media - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Irene Chernova is the 2023 Dostanic Award Recipient - Yale School of Medicine - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Sanders, HBCU medical schools in Atlanta to talk health care diversity - The Atlanta Journal Constitution - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Capital Area Health Consortium Honors UConn Health Nurse ... - University of Connecticut - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- Alzheimer's treatment Leqembi could cost Medicare up to $5 billion per year, study estimates - CNBC - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]
- The COVID 'emergency' is over. Should I relax precautions or still ... - NPR - May 13th, 2023 [May 13th, 2023]